PDA

View Full Version : Spyderco Persian - first impressions



The Deacon
01-12-03, 11:28 PM
I already posted this on the Spyderco forum, but am taking the liberty of posting it here too for the benfit on anyone who does not visit that forum...

Checked the mailbox about an hour ago. It was the third time I'd checked it today and I'd just about given up hope. Considering I only purchased it with an eBay BIN on Thanksgiving Day it really was a stretch to even think it might get here today. But, thanks to super fast shipping by Sawyers, and excellent service by my local Post Office, I now hold in my hands a new Ed Shempp Persian. Well ok, had to put it down to type this, I type slow enough as it is working with two hands, but you know what I mean.

First impressions:

This knife is awesome. Fit and finish are excellent. Ed's reference to it as "this vault of a knife" was no exaggeration, the blade is 1/8" thick, and the spine remains this thickness for all but the last inch of its 3 1/2" length. It is sandwiched between a pair of steel liners each about 3/64" thick. Add in the lockbar, back-strap, and those beautiful stainless bolsters, and you have an super solid framework to hang the matte finish black micarta scales on. In size it is similar to the Ayoob, the Shabaria, and the JD Smith, but weighs considerably more than any of them. I'd almost swear it weighs as much as any two of them together.

In my smallish hands the fit is perfect, my four fingers settle in with room to spare and the matte finish micarta give me confidence it will stay where I put it. Hole placement is excellent, the blade opens smoothly and easily with no feeling of over-reaching, although IMHO the hole could be bigger for easier operation with gloved hands. Lockup is typical of Spyderco front-lock folders - solid as a rock.

Forward grip is a bit scary though, the combination of a relatively shallow choil, no kick, and that wickedly sharp VG10 blade make some rather vivid images pop into my mind. Ok, I'll admit, I'm a bit paranoid to begin with, and the Native has me kind of spoiled in this regard, as it has to be about the ultimate "security blanket" for safe forward grip.

Personally, I fell that the black clip is more attractive on this knife than the shiny steel one on the prototype, as it does not compete for attention with the lines of the handle and blade. I do wish Sal would make a lefty clip for it, as this is one knife I would actually consider carrying clipped in my front pocket.

Danzo
01-12-03, 11:39 PM
Great review Paul. There is a good pic at www.knifecenter.com but the link to the exact page won't work when I post it. It is certainly an impressive looking knife. A brave name as well given the current political climate. It seems reasonably priced from your description and review.

:approve:

Danzo

The Deacon
01-12-03, 11:49 PM
Thanks Danzo, there are some good pics in this auction page http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=43335&item=2206709995 although they did get the blade length wrong in their description. MSRP is $135, street price here in the USA is considerably lower as you can see.

Regarding the name, similar thoughts crossed my mind, can't help but wonder if it will have an impact on sales.

Raoul Duke
02-12-03, 12:29 AM
That is a cool looking knife!!

ugug
02-12-03, 03:22 PM
wow..

that looks like the dogs things.. i bet with a little dremel ing it could be waved for rapid reverse grip opening..hmmmm :bandit: :D

as for the name .. hm .. wonder if 'persian' or 'republican' is a worse brand name at th emoment..

thanks deacs
:biggthump

ugug

The Deacon
02-12-03, 08:44 PM
wow..

that looks like the dogs things.. i bet with a little dremel ing it could be waved for rapid reverse grip opening..hmmmm :bandit: :D

as for the name .. hm .. wonder if 'persian' or 'republican' is a worse brand name at th emoment..

thanks deacs
:biggthump

ugug

YVW ugug, although I must admit that the "two nations divided by a common lanugauge" thing has come into play here. I have no idea if looking like "the dogs things" is good or bad. :D

I'm sure the Persian could be "waved", as I've seen it done to other Spydies with similar blade profiles. How well it would work is another question. The blade is one massive chunk of steel and, possibly because it's set up for tip up carry, Spyderco went with a pretty robust lock spring on this one. The result is that while the action is very smooth, it is a lot heavier than, for example a Delica, Endura, or Harpy. Makes me wonder if you'd tear up pockets like crazy practicing the wave with one. Do keep in mind though that I'm not into the whole SD knives thing, so my opinions on this issue are probably worthless.

Regarding the name, you may very well be right, although Democrat would be far worse. :D From another perspective, the combination of a non-agressive name plus the lack of a false edge, which some consider one of the hallmarks of a "fighting knife", may be good things for you folks in the UK.

ugug
02-12-03, 10:03 PM
"the dogs things"

good thing.. for male dogs.. helps them make lots of little dogs :biggthump